Finance is hugely important for businesses to aid
survival. It may be more difficult to
decide how it is best to structure the company finances. The main sources of finance are debt and
equity. Equity is a useful source
because payments can be delayed if the company want to use the money to invest
in the business. This is not possible if
a company is financed by debt because the money is offset against assets. However debt finance is ‘cheaper’ because
lenders require a lower rate of return compared to ordinary shareholders, debt
interest can be offset against pre tax profits and transaction cost of debt
finance is lower. Companies need to be
careful how much debt they have as even though increasing debt can reduce
Weighted Average Cost of Capital but it can increase the risk for shareholders
as it increases cost of equity and therefore shareholders also demand higher
returns. So how much debt and equity
finance should companies use?
The traditional view is that up to a point gearing will
increase shareholder wealth as cost of debt is less than cost of equity but as
cost of equity increases the WACC rises and shareholder wealth decreases.
Modigliani and Miller first challenged this
theory in 1958 and suggested that capital structure does not change the WACC
and so no optimal capital structure exists.
This was however criticised as it was based on unrealistic assumptions such
as no tax, no cost of liquidation, perfect capital markets exist and firms can
be classified in a distinct risk category.
After taking out most of these assumptions the WACC is shown to be at
its optimum when both debt and equity finance are used at similar or reasonable
amounts. Borrowing in extremes such as
all debt finance or all equity finance is avoided. This is because if you borrow the full amount
using equity finance the company loses the benefit of low cost debt but the
company would be too highly geared if the company used total equity finance.
However once
Modigliani and Miller modified the no tax assumption they found that a company
who aims for maximum shareholder value is better financed by mostly debt and
very little equity (Arnold, 2008 p793). The
problem however with this is taking on more debt can cause financial distress
which can lead to liquidation (Arnold, 2008 p 812). Mauer and Sarkar (2005) suggest that optimal
amount of debt finance is determined by tax deductibility of interest payments
and agency costs. Leland and Toft (1996)
agree with Mauer and Sarkar and also say that if agency costs are incurred the
riskier the firm is the less debt they should get and the company should also
aim to only need it for a short period of time. If high bankruptcy costs are
relevant then the company should obtain long term debt, but this would lead to
less tax advantage.
It is likely therefore that the amount of debt and equity
finance a company should obtain will be determined by many factors but 100% of
either is avoided as it is seen as too risky to have all your finance obtained
from one source. The main determinants
appear to be weighing up the tax deductable advantage, financial distress, bankruptcy
costs and agency costs. However other
factors could be Peeking order, financial slack, operating efficiency, industry
group gearing and reinvestment risk. Therefore
Modigliani and miller may be correct in saying there is no optimum financial
structure as it may be different for each company also depending on sector,
size, management and company risk.
Mauer, D. & Sarkar, S. (2005) ‘Real options, agency conflicts
and optimal capital structure’, Journal
of Banking and Finance, 29(6) pp. 1405-1428. SceinceDirect [Online]
Available at http://jr3tv3gd5w.search.serialssolutions.com/?ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&ctx_enc=info%3Aofi%2Fenc%3AUTF-8&rfr_id=info:sid/summon.serialssolutions.com&rft_val_fmt=info:ofi/fmt:kev:mtx:journal&rft.genre=article&rft.atitle=Real+options%2C+agency+conflicts%2C+and+optimal+capital+structure&rft.jtitle=Journal+of+Banking+and+Finance&rft.au=Mauer%2C+David+C&rft.au=Sarkar%2C+Sudipto&rft.date=2005-01-01&rft.pub=Elsevier+B.V&rft.issn=0378-4266&rft.volume=29&rft.issue=6&rft.spage=1405&rft.epage=1428&rft_id=info:doi/10.1016%2Fj.jbankfin.2004.05.036&rft.externalDocID=doi_10_1016_j_jbankfin_2004_05_036
Leland, H. & Toft, K. (1996) ‘Optimal Capital Structure,
Endogenous bankruptcy and the term structure of credit spreads’, The
Journal of Finance, 51(3) pp. 987-1019. JSTOR [Online] Available at http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.2307/2329229?origin=api&
Arnold, G. (2008) Corporate Financial Management. 4th
edn. FT Prentice Hall, Harlow.